This is the next post in a series of articles which addresses questions commonly raised by executors and heirs during a probate in our area. Our last article addressed the question of “can an executor decide who gets what in Texas?” The answer to that question is generally “no.” This does not mean, however, that an executor is required to simply follow the wishes of the heirs or beneficiaries. An experienced attorney can help an executor understand their obligations under the will. If you are in need of assistance then contact our office today to speak with a Dallas lawyer.
It is not the role of an executor to change a will or to attempt to unilaterally modify it. A last will and testament is a legally binding document which spells out the final wishes of the deceased. It is the role of the executor to carry out those wishes, not to simply impose their own desires onto the situation. This includes distributing the assets, as stated in the will, to the named beneficiaries. It does not matter if the executor does not personally approve of the heir or beneficiary or the heir or beneficiary thinks the will is somehow “unfair.” Additionally, it does not matter if the executor thinks that an inheritance is not in the individual’s best interest (i.e., if there are addiction issues). An executor who attempts to unilaterally go against the terms of the will may find themselves the subject of removal proceedings.
There are instances in which an executor may need to take action against a beneficiary, even though they cannot remove the individual from the will. An example of this would be situations in which the heir attempted to appropriate estate assets outside of probate. Suppose Joe Heir goes to the deceased’s home immediately after their death and takes $100,000 of artwork from the property. The will dictates that the art is to be given to Joe’s sister and Joe is to receive the deceased’s rare stamp collection. The executor contacts Joe and tells him to return the artwork. Joe refuses. Under this scenario, Joe may bring an action in Probate Court against Joe to force the return of the artwork. Joe may also be liable to the estate if the artwork is damaged. This is just one example of action which an executor may take against a beneficiary. The executor would not, however, be permitted to cut Joe out of the will.
An executor also may challenge the validity of the will which can impact the named heirs. Common reasons for challenging a last will and testament include fraud, duress, or the fact that the deceased lacked appropriate mental capacity when the instrument was signed. If the will is invalidated then the estate will be distributed in accordance with the next most recent valid will or, if there is not another valid will, then the distribution will be determined by Texas’ intestate succession laws. This means that all assets will be distributed in accordance with a rank-order that has been predetermined by the state. The wishes of the deceased will not be considered relevant. Suppose, for example, a will leaves a portion of an unmarried person’s estate to his or her children and another portion to their nieces and nephews. The will is invalidated. Under Texas law, the entire estate would go to the children. Again, the Court must rule that the will is invalid. The executor would not be able to disinherit the nieces and nephews on their own.
Dealing with heirs and beneficiaries can be one of the more difficult aspects of a probate case. Having a qualified attorney to assist you can help to ensure that the matter is handled as efficiently as possible. Our Dallas probate, trust, and estate lawyers are able to assist with such matters and we regularly represent personal representatives before the Probate Court. Contact us online or by telephone today to schedule an initial consultation. We also serve individuals throughout the state of Texas, including, but not limited to, the areas of Plano, Denton, Fort Worth, Garland, Irving, Frisco, McKinney, Austin, Houston, San Antonio, Tyler, Longview, Marshall, Nacogdoches, and Lufkin.